For a long time the sensible forecast for North America was that block pallets would make little headway. The 48x40 stringer pallet is cheaper, everybody has them, and the whole handling infrastructure is built around them.
All three of those facts still hold. What has changed is the mix of operations that buy pallets.
What is actually driving it
Automation tolerance. Automated storage and retrieval systems care about two things a forklift driver does not: overall height variance and squareness. A block pallet, built on a jig with nine blocks, is typically more dimensionally consistent than a stringer pallet, and more consistent than a *repaired* stringer pallet carrying a companion stringer that adds width at one edge.
As more warehouses put in conveyor transfers, shuttle systems and AS/RS, the cost of a jammed lane has gone up, and the pallet has become a tolerance problem rather than a purchasing one.
Pallet jack access. This is the one that bites operations after they have committed. A notched stringer pallet is four-way for a forklift and two-way for a manual pallet jack, because jack wheels need floor-level clearance that a notch does not provide. Operations that move to more manual picking tend to discover this.
Repairability. A damaged block can be replaced without disturbing the rest of the structure, and the pallet can stay in a higher grade. A cracked stringer needs a full-length companion, which is visible and usually costs a grade. Over a long service life in a closed loop, that difference compounds.
Failure mode. Stringer pallets tend to fail suddenly and visibly, with a crack at the notch. Block pallets tend to fail gradually at the block-to-board joint, usually as nail withdrawal. Sudden failure is worse in a rack. Gradual failure is worse if nobody inspects. Which one is preferable depends on inspection discipline, and operations with a real inspection process often prefer the gradual one.
What is holding it back, correctly
Cost. A block pallet uses more material and more labour. In open distribution, where pallets leave and do not come back, paying more per unit for durability that will never be realised is simply wrong.
The installed base. There are enormous numbers of 48x40 stringer pallets in North America. Recycled supply for them is deep and competitive. Recycled block pallet supply in this market is thin, which means the used-market economics that make stringer pallets so cheap do not yet apply.
Weight. Block pallets are generally heavier than a comparable GMA stringer pallet. Across a full truckload that is real freight.
Where the switch tends to happen
Not in general distribution. In three specific places:
- New automated facilities, where the pallet is specified as part of the system rather than bought afterwards
- Closed loops (plant to depot, same assets, high frequency) where durability is realised rather than theoretical
- Export programmes, where the destination market runs block anyway and dual-stocking two constructions is the real cost
In all three the buyer is making a total-cost decision rather than a unit-price decision, which is the only circumstance in which block wins.
The hybrid answer
Most operations that have moved did not move entirely. They run block in the automated portion and stringer everywhere else, and the reconciliation headache of two footprints is worth less than the jam rate they were getting.
That is a sensible outcome. Specify the construction for the process, not for the building.
What to do if you are evaluating
Count your jams. Not your pallet spend: your jams, your manual pallet-jack workarounds, and your rack-level pallet failures over twelve months. Put a cost on each.
If that number is small, stay with stringer and enjoy the cheapest pallets in the world. If it is not, the construction comparison is where to start, and a small first-article trial of block pallets in the affected process will tell you more than any amount of analysis. A partner supplier can quote either construction; request a quote to start.

